Skip to content
Provata Growth
All Posts

Don't Trust a Buying Signal Until You've Tested It on Your Own Customers

Mike Morris

Every lead vendor has a list of buying signals. Almost none can tell you whether those signals ever showed up before your customers bought.

A signal that works for one business can be useless for another. The only way to know is to test it against your own history.

Run the backtest first

The test is simple in principle. Take the customers you've already won. Go back to the year before each one signed, and check which signals were visible then.

On its own, that proves nothing. Lots of companies grow or hire. So you compare your customers against look-alike companies: same size, same location, same industry, but never customers. Draw that comparison group many times so one lucky draw can't fool you.

If your customers showed a signal about twice as often as their look-alikes, the signal is real for your business. If they showed it at the same rate, it's noise, however sensible it sounds.

Expect some favorites to fail

The failures are the most useful part. In real backtests, signals everyone assumes matter regularly show no difference at all. A popular sign of "maturity" can turn out to be just as common among companies that never bought.

Others surprise you the other way. A modest signal nobody was watching can beat the obvious ones. You won't find either without testing.

Know what a signal can and can't do

Be clear about what the test measures. A signal that separates customers from look-alikes tells you who is in the market. It doesn't necessarily tell you which existing lead will close.

That's not a weakness. It's a different job. Signals decide where outbound spends its time. Your sales process still decides who signs.

Also be honest about coverage. Public records won't match every customer. Often only about half can be tied to a filing, so results describe the half you can see.

What to do

Start with your own idea of a great prospect. List the signals you believe in, and add a few you've never considered. Test all of them against customers you've won, deals you've lost, and look-alikes that never engaged.

Keep what shows real lift. Drop what doesn't. Then repeat as new customers come in, because the test gets sharper with every win.

A buying signal is a hypothesis until your own customers prove it.

See How a Signal Backtest Works →

Get started

See Who’s Ready to Buy This Week.

Tell us what you sell and who you sell to. We’ll send a sample sheet built from real, current signals.